Back to BlogCriminal Defense

How to Hire a Criminal Defense Lawyer in Missouri: A Practical Guide

Jeff Goldfarb, Goldfarb Law Group
How to Hire a Criminal Defense Lawyer in Missouri: A Practical Guide

Facing a criminal charge — whether it is a DWI, a drug offense, or something more serious — is one of the most stressful experiences a person can go through. The stakes are high: your freedom, your record, your reputation, and your future are all on the line.

The lawyer you hire will have more influence over the outcome of your case than almost any other factor. Yet most people have never hired a criminal defense attorney before and have no idea where to start.

This guide walks you through exactly what to look for, what questions to ask, and what warning signs to watch out for.

Start With the Right Type of Lawyer

Criminal defense is its own distinct area of law. A lawyer who handles real estate closings or drafts wills is not the right person to defend you against a felony charge. You want someone whose practice is focused on criminal defense — someone who appears in criminal court regularly, knows the prosecutors and judges, and understands how the system actually works.

In Missouri, attorneys are not permitted to claim they "specialize" in a particular area of law. But you can — and should — ask directly: how much of your practice is criminal defense? How many criminal cases have you handled in the past year? How many have gone to trial?

The answers will tell you a great deal.

Questions to Ask Before You Hire Anyone

A good criminal defense lawyer will welcome your questions. Here is a checklist to bring to any consultation:

About their experience:

- How long have you been practicing criminal defense?

- How many cases like mine have you handled?

- Have you tried cases like mine before a jury?

- Are you familiar with the prosecutors and judges in this jurisdiction?

About your case:

- What are the potential outcomes in my situation?

- What is your honest assessment of the strengths and weaknesses of the case?

- What would your defense strategy look like?

- What are the key deadlines I need to be aware of?

About how they work:

- Will you personally handle my case, or will it be passed to an associate?

- How will you communicate with me, and how quickly do you typically respond?

- What are your fees, and what do they cover?

Pay close attention to how they answer — not just what they say. A lawyer who gives you a straight, honest assessment, even when it is not what you want to hear, is far more valuable than one who tells you everything will be fine.

Red Flags to Watch Out For

Super Lawyers has published a useful resource on warning signs of a bad lawyer that is worth reading. Here are the red flags that matter most in a criminal defense context:

Guaranteed outcomes. No honest lawyer can promise you a dismissal, an acquittal, or any specific result. Criminal cases involve too many variables — evidence, witnesses, judges, juries — for any outcome to be guaranteed. A lawyer who promises you a result is either misleading you or has not thought carefully about your case.

Poor communication from the start. If a lawyer or their office is slow to return your calls during the consultation phase — when they are trying to earn your business — imagine how responsive they will be once you have already paid. Communication is the number one complaint clients have about lawyers nationwide. Set your expectations clearly and find someone who meets them.

Pressure to settle quickly. Some lawyers push clients toward plea deals not because it is in the client's best interest, but because it is the path of least resistance. A good criminal defense lawyer evaluates every option — including going to trial — and advises you based on the facts of your case, not their own convenience.

Disorganization. A disorganized office is a warning sign. Files everywhere, missed callbacks, confusion about your case details — these are not minor quirks. In criminal defense, missed deadlines can be catastrophic. In Missouri, for example, you have only 15 days from a DWI arrest to request a hearing to challenge your license suspension. A disorganized lawyer can cost you rights you cannot get back.

Someone who just agrees with everything you say. You want a lawyer who gives you honest counsel, not one who simply validates whatever you believe. As one experienced attorney put it: "You want to be very wary of the overly aggressive lawyer who doesn't seem to be giving you advice but seems to simply be agreeing with you." A good lawyer will push back when necessary — that is part of the job.

Vague or evasive answers about fees. You should know exactly what you are paying for. Hidden fees, vague billing arrangements, or reluctance to put the fee agreement in writing are all warning signs.

What Separates a Great Criminal Defense Lawyer From an Average One

Experience in the courtroom is the single biggest differentiator. Many criminal defense lawyers rarely — if ever — go to trial. They handle volume, move cases quickly, and resolve most matters through plea agreements. That approach may be appropriate in some situations, but it is not a substitute for genuine trial experience.

A lawyer who has tried cases before juries — and won — brings something different to every case. Prosecutors know who is willing to fight and who is not. That reputation affects how cases are negotiated long before they ever reach a courtroom.

Beyond trial experience, look for:

- Personal attention. In a large firm, your case may be handled by a junior associate you never met. In a smaller practice focused on criminal defense, you are more likely to work directly with the attorney who is actually responsible for your outcome.

- Knowledge of local courts. Criminal defense is intensely local. Knowing the prosecutors, the judges, and the unwritten rules of a particular courthouse matters enormously.

- Honest communication. The best lawyers tell you the truth about your situation — including the parts that are hard to hear — so you can make informed decisions.

- A track record of results. Ask about dismissals, acquittals, and reduced charges. Past results are not a guarantee of future outcomes, but they tell you something about how a lawyer approaches their work.

Do Not Wait to Make the Call

In criminal cases, time is almost always working against you. Evidence can disappear. Witnesses' memories fade. Deadlines pass. The earlier you have an experienced lawyer involved, the more options you have.

If you or someone you care about is facing criminal charges in Missouri, the most important thing you can do right now is get qualified legal counsel on your side — someone who will be honest with you, fight for you, and stand by you through every stage of the process.

Schedule a free, confidential consultation with Jeff Goldfarb — 30 years of criminal defense experience, and a lawyer who will personally handle your case from start to finish.

Facing a DWI Charge in Missouri?

Jeff Goldfarb offers free, confidential consultations. Call or text anytime.

Call (314) 229-1028

This article is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.